Skip to content
Free Shipping on Orders $75 and up. 12/17: Last day for holiday shipping! (Ground ONLY)
Free Shipping on Orders $75 and up.

Free Mystery Gift

The holiday spirit is running high here at TSE, get a FREE Mystery Gift* with every order over $89.99†!  The more you order, the BETTER the FREE Mystery Gift!  

    • Spend $90 get a FREE  
      • Buffalo Bills Christmas Ornament, or
      • Buffalo Bills Lanyard (Blue or Red), or
      • Buffalo Bills 1,000 Piece Jigsaw Puzzle
    • Spend $150 get a FREE 
      • Mystery 8x10 photo
    • Spend $275 get a FREE
      • Mystery 8x10 with Mystery Bills Licensed Merchandise, or
      • 2 Mystery 8x10 photos, or
      • Mystery Puck with Bills Christmas Ornament
    • Spend $400 get a FREE
      • Mystery 16x20 Photo, or
      • Mystery Mini Helmet, or
      • Mystery Football, or
    • Spend $550 get a FREE
      • Mystery Mini Helmet / Puck Bundle or 
      • Mystery Football / Puck Bundle

* Mystery Gifts consist of current, former, retired and/or ex-players.  The popularity of the players in these Mystery Gifts vary, and do not have a guaranteed value.  These gifts could be players from the Bills, Sabres, Bandits, college or entertainment.  They could be full priced, discounted or close-outs items.  The values shown in the free Mystery Gift call out page is based on current Mystery Box pricing and used only as a benchmark.  To reiterate, these are FREE GIFTS, no pricing was inflated or discounts changed to "make-up" for the free gifts.  We make no guarantees of actual value.

†Order total used for the Free Mystery gift does NOT include pre-sale, Facebook auctions, Josh Allen collection, products with selling price over $525 and Mystery Box items. The pricing for those items is not included in this promotion. Other exclusions may apply.

TSE Buffalo reserves the right to change Free gift(s) and value levels at any time.

Save up to 35% Save %
$86.99 - $92.99
$86.99 - $92.99
$86.99
$56.99 - $59.99
$56.99 - $59.99
$56.99

A.J Epenesa Signed Arms out in Blue Photo

AJ Epenesa Signed Arms out in Blue Photo. This item comes with TSE AUTHENTICATION (an $8 value) and a 100% Money Back Authenticity Guarantee. Tota...

View full details
$86.99 - $92.99
$86.99 - $92.99
$86.99
$56.99 - $59.99
$56.99 - $59.99
$56.99
Save up to 35% Save %
A.J Epenesa Signed Pick Six vs the Washington Commanders Photo Signed Photos TSE Buffalo Save up to 35% Save %
$86.99 - $108.99
$86.99 - $108.99
$86.99
$56.99 - $70.99
$56.99 - $70.99
$56.99

A.J Epenesa Signed Pick Six vs the Washington Commanders Photo

AJ Epenesa Signed Pick Six vs the Washington Commanders Photo. This item comes with TSE AUTHENTICATION (an $8 value) and a 100% Money Back Authenti...

View full details
$86.99 - $108.99
$86.99 - $108.99
$86.99
$56.99 - $70.99
$56.99 - $70.99
$56.99
Save up to 35% Save %
Save up to 35% Save %
$86.99 - $92.99
$86.99 - $92.99
$86.99
$56.99 - $59.99
$56.99 - $59.99
$56.99

A.J Epenesa Signed Sacking Aaron Rodgers Photo

AJ Epenesa Signed Sacking Aaron Rodgers Photo. This item comes with TSE AUTHENTICATION (an $8 value) and a 100% Money Back Authenticity Guarantee. ...

View full details
$86.99 - $92.99
$86.99 - $92.99
$86.99
$56.99 - $59.99
$56.99 - $59.99
$56.99
Save up to 35% Save %
Save 34% Save %
$86.99
$86.99 - $86.99
$86.99
$56.99
$56.99 - $56.99
$56.99

AJ Epenesa Signed Running with Ball vs Panthers 8x10 Photo - Horizontal

AJ Epenesa Signed Running with Ball vs Panthers 8x10 Photo - Horizontal This item comes with TSE AUTHENTICATION (an $8 value) and a 100% Money Back...

View full details
$86.99
$86.99 - $86.99
$86.99
$56.99
$56.99 - $56.99
$56.99
Save 34% Save %
Sold out
$69.99
$69.99 - $69.99
$69.99
$45.99
$45.99 - $45.99
$45.99

Alec Anderson Signed Close-up in Blue 8x10 Photo

Alec Anderson Signed Close-up in Blue 8x10 Photo. This item comes with TSE AUTHENTICATION (an $8 value) and a 100% Money Back Authenticity Guarante...

View full details
$69.99
$69.99 - $69.99
$69.99
$45.99
$45.99 - $45.99
$45.99
Sold out
Save up to 35% Save %
$86.99 - $108.99
$86.99 - $108.99
$86.99
$56.99 - $70.99
$56.99 - $70.99
$56.99

Andre Reed Signed Arms up in End Zone Photo

Andre Reed Signed Arms up in End Zone Photo This item comes with TSE AUTHENTICATION and a 100% Money Back Authenticity Guarantee. Total Sports Ent...

View full details
$86.99 - $108.99
$86.99 - $108.99
$86.99
$56.99 - $70.99
$56.99 - $70.99
$56.99
Save up to 35% Save %
Billy Shaw Signed Sitting on Bench 8x10 Photo with HOF 99 Signed Photos TSE Buffalo
Save 34% Save %
$86.99
$86.99 - $86.99
$86.99
$56.99
$56.99 - $56.99
$56.99

Billy Shaw Signed Sitting on Bench 8x10 Photo with HOF 99

Billy Shaw Signed Sitting on Bench 8x10 Photo with HOF 99.  This item come with TSE Authentication and Money Back Authenticity Guarantee. Total S...

View full details
$86.99
$86.99 - $86.99
$86.99
$56.99
$56.99 - $56.99
$56.99
Save 34% Save %
Save up to 35% Save %
$51.99 - $56.99
$51.99 - $56.99
$51.99
$33.99 - $36.99
$33.99 - $36.99
$33.99

Brad May Signed Buffalo Sabres Fighting vs Rangers Photo

Brad May Signed Buffalo Sabres Fighting vs Ranger Photo. This item comes with TSE AUTHENTICATION (an $8 value) and a 100% Money Back Authenticity G...

View full details
$51.99 - $56.99
$51.99 - $56.99
$51.99
$33.99 - $36.99
$33.99 - $36.99
$33.99
Save up to 35% Save %
Brad May Signed Buffalo Sabres Fighting vs Rangers Photo with "May Day" Signed Photos TSE Buffalo
Save up to 35% Save %
$62.99 - $68.99
$62.99 - $68.99
$62.99
$40.99 - $44.99
$40.99 - $44.99
$40.99

Brad May Signed Buffalo Sabres Fighting vs Rangers Photo with "May Day"

Brad May Signed Buffalo Sabres Fighting vs Ranger Photo with "May Day" This item comes with TSE AUTHENTICATION (an $8 value) and a 100% Money Back ...

View full details
$62.99 - $68.99
$62.99 - $68.99
$62.99
$40.99 - $44.99
$40.99 - $44.99
$40.99
Save up to 35% Save %
Save 35% Save %
$83.99
$83.99 - $83.99
$83.99
$54.99
$54.99 - $54.99
$54.99

Brad May Signed Standing Next to RJ Display 16x20 Photo with "Thank You Rick"

Brad May Signed Standing Next to RJ Display 16x20 Photo with "Thank You Rick". This item comes with TSE Digital Authentication (an $8 value) and a ...

View full details
$83.99
$83.99 - $83.99
$83.99
$54.99
$54.99 - $54.99
$54.99
Save 35% Save %
Brandon Beane Signed Talking with McDermott 16x20 Photo with Trust the Process Signed Photos TSE Buffalo
Save up to 35% Save %
$97.99 - $113.99
$97.99 - $113.99
$97.99
$63.99 - $73.99
$63.99 - $73.99
$63.99

Brandon Beane Signed Talking with McDermott Photo with Trust the Process

Brandon Beane Signed Talking with McDermott Photo with Trust the Process. This item comes with TSE AUTHENTICATION and a 100% Money Back Authenticit...

View full details
$97.99 - $113.99
$97.99 - $113.99
$97.99
$63.99 - $73.99
$63.99 - $73.99
$63.99
Save up to 35% Save %
Casey Mittelstadt Signed Skating Celebration 8x10 Photo CLEARANCE TSE Buffalo
Save 35% Save %
$90.99
$90.99 - $90.99
$90.99
$59.14
$59.14 - $59.14
$59.14

Casey Mittelstadt Signed Skating Celebration 8x10 Photo

Casey Mittelstadt Signed Skating Celebration 8x10 Photo This item comes with TSE AUTHENTICATION (an $8 value) and a 100% Money Back Authenticity Gu...

View full details
$90.99
$90.99 - $90.99
$90.99
$59.14
$59.14 - $59.14
$59.14
Save 35% Save %
Casey Mittelstadt Skating in Blue Signed 8x10 Photo Signed Photos TSE Buffalo
Save 35% Save %
$86.99
$86.99 - $86.99
$86.99
$56.54
$56.54 - $56.54
$56.54

Casey Mittelstadt Skating in Blue Signed 8x10 Photo

Casey Mittelstadt Skating in Blue Signed 8x10 Photo This item comes with TSE AUTHENTICATION (an $8 value) and a 100% Money Back Authenticity Guaran...

View full details
$86.99
$86.99 - $86.99
$86.99
$56.54
$56.54 - $56.54
$56.54
Save 35% Save %
Casey Mittelstadt Skating with Stick up Signed 16x20 Photo Signed Photos TSE Buffalo
Save 50% Save %
$107.99
$107.99 - $107.99
$107.99
$53.99
$53.99 - $53.99
$53.99

Casey Mittelstadt Skating with Stick up Signed 16x20 Photo

Casey Mittelstadt Skating with Stick up Signed 16x20 Photo This item comes with TSE AUTHENTICATION (an $8 value) and a 100% Money Back Authenticity...

View full details
$107.99
$107.99 - $107.99
$107.99
$53.99
$53.99 - $53.99
$53.99
Save 50% Save %
Casey Mittelstadt Stick Up In White Signed 8x10 Photo CLEARANCE TSE Buffalo
Save 35% Save %
$90.99
$90.99 - $90.99
$90.99
$59.14
$59.14 - $59.14
$59.14

Casey Mittelstadt Stick Up In White Signed 8x10 Photo

Casey Mittelstadt Stick Up In White Signed 8x10 Photo This item comes with TSE AUTHENTICATION (an $8 value) and a 100% Money Back Authenticity Guar...

View full details
$90.99
$90.99 - $90.99
$90.99
$59.14
$59.14 - $59.14
$59.14
Save 35% Save %
Casey Mittelstadt Taking a Shot in Blue Signed 8x10 Photo Signed Photos TSE Buffalo
Save 35% Save %
$90.99
$90.99 - $90.99
$90.99
$59.14
$59.14 - $59.14
$59.14

Casey Mittelstadt Taking a Shot in Blue Signed 8x10 Photo

Casey Mittelstadt Taking a Shot in Blue Signed 8x10 Photo This item comes with TSE AUTHENTICATION (an $8 value) and a 100% Money Back Authenticity ...

View full details
$90.99
$90.99 - $90.99
$90.99
$59.14
$59.14 - $59.14
$59.14
Save 35% Save %
Casey Mittelstadt Taking a Shot in White Signed 8x10 Photo Signed Photos TSE Buffalo
Save 35% Save %
$90.99
$90.99 - $90.99
$90.99
$59.14
$59.14 - $59.14
$59.14

Casey Mittelstadt Taking a Shot in White Signed 8x10 Photo

Casey Mittelstadt Taking a Shot in White Signed 8x10 Photo This item comes with TSE AUTHENTICATION (an $8 value) and a 100% Money Back Authenticity...

View full details
$90.99
$90.99 - $90.99
$90.99
$59.14
$59.14 - $59.14
$59.14
Save 35% Save %
Casey Mittelstadt Taking Shot Signed 16x20 Photo Signed Photos TSE Buffalo
Save 50% Save %
$107.99
$107.99 - $107.99
$107.99
$53.99
$53.99 - $53.99
$53.99

Casey Mittelstadt Taking Shot Signed 16x20 Photo

Casey Mittelstadt Taking Shot Signed 16x20 Photo This item comes with TSE AUTHENTICATION (an $8 value) and a 100% Money Back Authenticity Guarantee...

View full details
$107.99
$107.99 - $107.99
$107.99
$53.99
$53.99 - $53.99
$53.99
Save 50% Save %
Chevy Chase + Randy Quaid Dual Signed Christmas Vacation 16x20 Photo Signed Movie TSE Buffalo
Save 35% Save %
$611.99
$611.99 - $611.99
$611.99
$397.99
$397.99 - $397.99
$397.99

Chevy Chase + Randy Quaid Dual Signed Christmas Vacation 16x20 Photo

Chevy Chase + Randy Quaid Dual Signed Christmas Vacation 16x20 Photo This item comes with BECKETT AUTHENTICATION (an $8 value) and a 100% Money Bac...

View full details
$611.99
$611.99 - $611.99
$611.99
$397.99
$397.99 - $397.99
$397.99
Save 35% Save %
Save up to 35% Save %
$122.99 - $128.99
$122.99 - $128.99
$122.99
$79.99 - $83.99
$79.99 - $83.99
$79.99

Christian Benford Signed Arms out Celebration vs Bengals Photo

Christian Benford Signed Arms out Celebration vs Bengals Photo. This item comes with TSE AUTHENTICATION and a 100% Money Back Authenticity Guarante...

View full details
$122.99 - $128.99
$122.99 - $128.99
$122.99
$79.99 - $83.99
$79.99 - $83.99
$79.99
Save up to 35% Save %
Christian Benford Signed Catching in Snow Photo Signed Photos TSE Buffalo
Save up to 35% Save %
$122.99 - $128.99
$122.99 - $128.99
$122.99
$79.99 - $83.99
$79.99 - $83.99
$79.99

Christian Benford Signed Catching in Snow Photo

Christian Benford Signed Catching in Snow Photo This item comes with TSE AUTHENTICATION and a 100% Money Back Authenticity Guarantee. Total Sports...

View full details
$122.99 - $128.99
$122.99 - $128.99
$122.99
$79.99 - $83.99
$79.99 - $83.99
$79.99
Save up to 35% Save %
Save up to 35% Save %
$122.99 - $128.99
$122.99 - $128.99
$122.99
$79.99 - $83.99
$79.99 - $83.99
$79.99

Christian Benford Signed Highpoint Interception vs Bengals Photo

Christian Benford Signed Highpoint Interception vs Bengals Photo. This item comes with TSE AUTHENTICATION and a 100% Money Back Authenticity Guaran...

View full details
$122.99 - $128.99
$122.99 - $128.99
$122.99
$79.99 - $83.99
$79.99 - $83.99
$79.99
Save up to 35% Save %
Christian Benford Signed Interception Celebration with Terrel Bernard Photo Signed Photos TSE Buffalo
Save up to 35% Save %
$122.99 - $128.99
$122.99 - $128.99
$122.99
$79.99 - $83.99
$79.99 - $83.99
$79.99

Christian Benford Signed Interception Celebration with Terrel Bernard Photo

Christian Benford Signed Interception Celebration with Terrel Bernard Photo. This item comes with TSE AUTHENTICATION and a 100% Money Back Authenti...

View full details
$122.99 - $128.99
$122.99 - $128.99
$122.99
$79.99 - $83.99
$79.99 - $83.99
$79.99
Save up to 35% Save %
Save up to 35% Save %
$122.99 - $143.99
$122.99 - $143.99
$122.99
$79.99 - $93.99
$79.99 - $93.99
$79.99

Christian Benford Signed Pick Six vs Bengals Photo

Christian Benford Signed Pick Six vs Bengals Photo. This item comes with TSE AUTHENTICATION and a 100% Money Back Authenticity Guarantee. Total Sp...

View full details
$122.99 - $143.99
$122.99 - $143.99
$122.99
$79.99 - $93.99
$79.99 - $93.99
$79.99
Save up to 35% Save %